Mesmerize Eyeliner


Mesmerize Eyeliner

Returns are always on us!
  • Safe eyeliner stays put
  • Rich colors with skin conditioners
  • Built-in tool enables easy blending
Draw the Line

Define your eyes, without compromise. This gentle formulation glides on easily, without pulling or leaving lids covered in aging, drying chemicals. The rich color stays put, and the built-in blender provides easy-to-smudge perfection.

Starting with a freshly sharpened pencil, run across lids and smudge with built-in blender for your desired effect, from natural to more dramatic.


This gentle eyeliner is our hands-down favorite for sensitive eyes. Sarah Rose, our Soho makeup artist likes it smudged into top lashes, not in that water line.


About The Brand

In Taos, New Mexico, creativity and alchemy collide to create Vapour. These lit-from-within, high-performing cosmetics combine the purest, active ingredients found in the earth to nourish as they lend radiance.

Shop All Vapour

Customer Reviews

  • Had to return

    Erin M. January 09, 2019

    The color was good but I had to return it; I found that the product fell on my face during the day.

  • Not as great as I hoped

    Molly M. November 27, 2018

    I submitted a review for this product earlier but was reviewing the wrong eyeliner! (I was thinking about my Dr. Haushka liner instead). This product is OK. Color is nice, but its a little too soft of a pencil and it tends to run through the day. It’s a decent option for what it is, but certainly not my top choice for natural liners.

  • Stays on all day

    Molly M. November 15, 2018

    Great pigment to this liner. I put it on in the morn and it literally lasts all day, and doesn’t run down my face! It’s super easy to take off. I use the purple (I have dark hair and light hazel eyes) and I get a ton of compliments. Highly recommend. Love the little smudger on the end, too!

  • Returned

    Laura M. November 12, 2018

    This eyeliner isn’t great. It does go on very opaque – you really have to press down hard. I also found it was mostly under my eyes and on my upper eyelid by the end of the workday.

  • Great color and stay

    Brittany D. September 16, 2018

    This eyeliner pencil glides on smooth and the color lasts all night. I love that the pencil has a smudger too, which makes it easy to create a smokey eye effect.

  • Great for those who like smudgy eyeliner!

    Erin I. August 16, 2018

    Really easy to apply with rich color that’s easy to blend/smudge. I don’t wear a ton of makeup and prefer a smudged eyeliner look over the effect liquid liner will give you, so this is perfect for me. If you want something with a little more boldness, this isn’t for you. Only 4 stars, because I wish it stayed on a little bit better, but it’s definitely a fantastic natural option. Next best thing to the estee lauder eye duo that I used to be obsessed with before they discontinued it and it’s a lot healthier!

  • Solid

    Emma P. March 14, 2018

    Compared to other pencil eyeliners, this is a solid choice, but it still doesn’t give *quite* enough pigment with a light application.

  • Just Ok

    Marissa T. February 23, 2018

    I ordered the Truffle color which looks brown on the website but it isn’t, it’s more of a gray/slate. This also reminds me more of a khol and smudges a little too easily. I prefer the Beautycounter pencil because it stays put and the brown is actually brown.

    • From Follain:

      Hi Marissa, I am so sorry this wasn’t as expected! I would recommend trying the Kjaer Weis Eye Pencil in Brown for more of a true brown color!

  • No problems

    Keely Y. February 17, 2018

    No problems with this eyeliner so far! Applies on smooth and even

  • Soft and glides on easy

    Wynne L. January 31, 2018

    Love that I’m keeping chemicals away from my sensitive eyes. The blending tip makes it super easy to a apply a natural line

  • Best natural world eyeliner I’ve found

    Am January 19, 2018

    I have truly struggled with disappointing green beauty eyeliners that are not black enough or migrate all over your face. This Vapor liner is a great option, very black and stays put well. The best I have found in green beauty. Gentle for contact wearers.

  • Excellent eyeliner

    Angie December 30, 2017

    I’ve been a LONG time wearer of drugstore eyeliner and finally decided to splurge and treat myself to an upgrade. I was nervous about a natural product holding up, but this eyeliner has exceeded expectations! I went with the truffle color, and it is a lovely dark brown. The color goes on smoothly and is easy to blend in with the smudging end. I’ve had no issues with the eyeliner smearing or smudging throughout the day. It stays put and comes off easily with a warm washcloth and a little coconut oil.

  • Clean lines and stays on!

    Abigail L. October 16, 2017

    I recently tried this for the first time and love this eyeliner! It goes on beautifully and, most importantly, stays on throughout the day.

  • Extremely easy to apply!

    Carla P. October 14, 2017

    I love this eyeliner. I even use it as a brow pencil from time to time. It stays all day and has really nice clean edges. The smudger end isn’t the best, but I don’t even really need to use it.

  • performs well

    Jacqueline A. October 01, 2017

    for me, this product is exactly what i need. i don’t put on makeup very often but whenever i feel like i need a little something extra i usually just use eyeliner and this stuff works great. smooth application and stays put throughout the day. it also creates a fairly precise line to the point that i can use it on my top lid if i’m feeling like i really need some extra oomph.

  • Pretty eyeliner

    Rachel M. September 30, 2017

    Beautiful color. Goes on much easier then other “healthy beauty” eye liners I’ve tried.

  • makeup

    Susan P. September 29, 2017


  • Perfect eyeliner!

    Marie S. September 28, 2017

    Everything I want in eyeliner. Goes on smooth, can be smudged on purpose but not by accident. And the tool on the end is actually useful!

  • Michelle B. September 28, 2017
  • Not the color I was expecting

    Emily G. September 06, 2017

    The Truffle color is not at all like the photo. It’s more of a light gray, which is fairly disappointing but not the worst thing in the world. It’s also not very creamy and kind of hard to get a good amount on your eye.

  • Obsessed with truffle

    Grace A. August 09, 2017

    LOVE this eyeliner in truffle. I never wore eyeliner but this is so natural that I wear it on an everyday basis. I layer it on for evenings for a more dramatic look. I have amber/light brown eyes and it compliments them very nicely.

  • amazing eyeliner!

    Jenna L. April 26, 2016

    This is an incredible eyeliner! The truffle shade is great for people with hazel/light brown eyes. It really brings out the color in your eyes in a unique way! It works either as a fine line or smudged a little for a softer look. It feels so clean and doesn’t irritate my eyes at all!

  • Great color, easy to use

    Annie February 24, 2016

    Very easy application and great smudging…

  • Great Eyeliner

    Klo36 July 17, 2015

    I just started using this about a week ago and I love it. My eyes are a bit sensitive, and this pencil goes on so easily and wears well all day without any irritation. I was worried about it bleeding/running and it does that a little bit over the course of a long day, but so did the very expensive pencil I previously used. I would even say this is slightly better, so I’ll take this organic product over that any day! As another reviewer stated the pencil is softer so you might go through it a little faster, but I haven’t been using it long enough to really notice that. But it also costs half what I was paying for before, so I don’t see that as a problem. Overall, it’s a great eyeliner and I’m glad I tried it!

  • Nice application

    Susan February 28, 2015

    This is my favorite natural eyeliner. It goes on smoothly and doesn’t tug at your lid. It smudges very well and lasts all day.

  • Works Great

    Renee February 21, 2015

    This eye liner goes on perfectly smooth and lasts all day. It’s much softer than most eye liners, so I tend to go through product much quicker.